C2 Proficiency Essay (Part 1): How to Write It, Sample Answer & Feedback
The Writing paper of the Cambridge C2 Proficiency exam has an unsavoury reputation. First, it consists of two diametrically different tasks, and on top of that, the compulsory essay - Part 1 - requires a form of synthesis that is unique to the Proficiency exam.
For outsiders, those who have never prepared for the exam using conventional coursebooks such as Objective, Masterclass or Expert, to name but a few, it can be a formidable obstacle. In fact, even those who have some experience writing this kind of essay more often than not struggle to produce an effective and coherent piece. Today, we are going to shed some light on how we teach this kind of task at AEE.
But first things first: what exactly is this task? You are going to read two short texts (about 100 words each) on a related topic. The texts typically resemble extracts from reputable sources, such as newspaper or magazine articles and books. Our task is to write an essay summarising and evaluating the four key points from both texts. We should use our own words throughout as far as possible and include our own ideas. The recommended word count is 240–280 words.
So, an effective essay should ultimately present an argument that addresses the key points from both texts. This is crucial. It is erroneous to think that the task is purely mechanical—simply paraphrase the ideas and say whether you agree or disagree—as some people assume. The text we produce has to be a coherent whole, which means that the ideas are presented in a clear and logical way—not just superficial source-by-source reporting.
An effective essay should recognise the contrasting or complementary nature of the ideas in the input texts and bring them together in a coherent synthesis. Rather than simply dealing with each point in isolation, we should establish meaningful connections between the arguments and develop our own line of thought.
This can be achieved by following these steps:
- Read the texts' titles. This is obvious, but some neglect it or pay too little attention to them. A title usually provides clues to the main idea of a text, and the key points you are expected to find will develop this idea.
- Read the texts and identify the key ideas. The easiest way to do this is by distinguishing the main arguments from the explanations and examples that support them. Each text generally contains two key points.
- Compare the key points from both texts. Are they contrasting or complementary? Are there ideas that are somehow connected? This will help you structure your essay.
- Think about whether you agree or disagree with the authors. How could you qualify or challenge their assumptions? A nice life hack is to ask whether what they claim is always true, whether their ideas are somewhat idealistic or whether there are important limitations or implications worth considering.
- Spend some time planning, collecting your thoughts and creating a word cloud of useful vocabulary. Later, when you write your piece, it should be easier to express your ideas precisely and naturally if you already have some useful words and expressions in front of you.
- Write an introduction in which you clearly establish the central issue raised by the two texts. You do not necessarily need to introduce each text separately.
- In your body paragraphs, make sure your own evaluation plays a central role. Remember, the key points should be summarised, not simply restated in different words. Be concise, but make sure all four points are adequately addressed and integrated into your argument.
- Make sure you proofread your work. Cambridge assesses not only the range of grammar and vocabulary you use, but also your accuracy and control. Occasional slips are unlikely to be decisive, but recurring grammatical mistakes, including errors with articles or prepositions, may affect your Language score.
- As you write, make sure your message is clear and your ideas progress logically. Build on what you have already said rather than getting lost in the vortex of your own thoughts.
- Finally, do not be long-winded. 240–280 words is enough. You can exceed the recommended word count without an automatic penalty, but if you write 500 words, you might get sidetracked and write something irrelevant. And, more dangerously, you could end up with far too little time to write the second piece, which is even longer.
Here's a sample task and answer that we used in a lesson on our C2 Proficiency Part-Time course. Analyse the task first, then read the sample answer and examine the teacher's feedback. Then write your own piece. With consistent, regular practice, you will soon be able to complete these tasks not only quickly but also effectively.
C2 Proficiency Essay: Sample Task
Read the two texts below. Write an essay summarising and evaluating the key points from both texts. Use your own words throughout as far as possible, and include your own ideas in your answer.
Text 1 — Modern Tourism
Global tourism has experienced continued growth and deepening diversification in the latter decades of the twentieth century. It has made it possible for us to travel the world and broaden our horizons, diminishing our attachment to cultural stereotypes. And this cultural value is not the only aspect to be considered. The more people travel around the world, the greater the economic benefits to host countries. Destinations around the world which might otherwise have stagnated financially can flourish as tourists explore attractions and natural landscapes which are often the key reason for the initial interest in the area.
Text 2 — Impacts of Tourism
It appears that people travelling around the world are oblivious to the detrimental effects of mass tourism. This can be clearly seen in the case of industry leaders undercutting small local businesses in popular tourist destinations. Governments around the world appear to neglect this issue and actively promote mass tourism for financial reasons. And as tourism numbers grow, so does environmental degradation due to air travel emissions and land pollution. Only serious action from local authorities is likely to resolve economic and environmental issues arising from the tourism industry.
Sample Answer: Tourism
There is no denying that tourism is a thorny issue, giving rise to heated discussions. The two texts take diametrically opposed perspectives, with the first advocating its benefits and the second highlighting its drawbacks.
The first text draws attention to travellers' deeper understanding of the world. This is a fair point, as only by trotting around the globe can individuals see with their own eyes how people in other countries live; books and TV programmes cannot fully substitute for this first-hand experience. Furthermore, the author raises an arguably more important economic point, claiming that tourism boosts local economies. While this may be true, such gains do not necessarily translate into prosperity for local communities.
In fact, upon closer inspection, it becomes apparent that tourism may stifle smaller enterprises, as the second author argues. Local B&Bs, restaurants and shops can fight a losing battle against international corporations, even as governments continue promoting mass tourism for financial reasons. Equally troubling are the dire consequences for the environment: air-travel emissions contribute to pollution, while pristine landscapes can be transformed by money-making projects. The second author's call for intervention by local authorities is therefore persuasive, although restrictions must be balanced against communities' dependence on tourism.
I mostly agree with the second author. While tourism can positively influence our perception of the world, it often comes at too high a price. Government action is essential, but travellers should also embrace mindful travel: supporting local businesses and treating the environment with care. Such efforts could help ensure that the benefits celebrated in the first text become a reality.
Teacher's Feedback
Content — Band 5
All content is relevant to the task, and the target reader is fully informed. You successfully summarise and evaluate the key points from both texts, addressing the cultural, economic and environmental dimensions of tourism. Your evaluation goes beyond summary, particularly when you question whether economic benefits actually reach local communities. Your own ideas about responsible travel and government intervention are relevant and effectively integrated.
Communicative Achievement — Band 4
You demonstrate a strong command of essay conventions, communicating complex ideas in an effective and convincing way. Your discussion is appropriately analytical, and your arguments are supported by relevant examples.
To push your grade further, consider: avoiding somewhat formulaic introductory expressions such as “There is no denying” and “a thorny issue, giving rise to heated discussions”. A more purposeful opening would help demonstrate the complete command of the conventions of the communicative task expected at Band 5.
Organisation — Band 4
Your essay is a well-organised, coherent whole, using a variety of cohesive devices and organisational patterns with flexibility. The progression from tourism's benefits to its disadvantages and possible solutions is logical and easy to follow.
To push your grade further, consider: integrating the arguments from both texts more consistently, rather than discussing them largely in separate paragraphs. This would demonstrate the complete flexibility and more impressive organisation expected at Band 5.
Language — Band 4
You use a wide range of vocabulary, including less common lexis, with fluency, precision and sophistication. Your grammar is sophisticated, fully controlled and natural, with no significant inaccuracies.
To push your grade further, consider: refining lexical precision and register, particularly “diametrically opposed perspectives”, which overstates the contrast, and “trotting around the globe”, which is rather informal for this essay. Greater consistency in these choices would strengthen the precision and style expected at Band 5.
Total: 17/20
Good luck with your exam!
The AEE Team